Study Sparks Debate on Accuracy of Genome Tests for Cancer Patients

Finding suggests tests could lead doctors to prescribe ineffective drugs in up to half of cases

A new study has triggered a dispute over the accuracy of genomic tests that are increasingly used to match cancer patients with drugs that attack their tumors. WSJ’s Ron Winslow reports.

A new study has triggered a dispute about the accuracy of genomic tests that are increasingly used to match cancer patients with drugs that attack their tumors.

The study, published Wednesday by researchers at Johns Hopkins’ Sidney Kimmel Comprehensive Cancer Center, suggests that such tests could lead doctors to prescribe an ineffective drug in up to half of cases. The reason: The tests, which analyze tumor DNA, typically don’t also analyze normal DNA from the same patient, a step the researchers said could eliminate false positive results.

But Foundation Medicine Inc., the most prominent provider of such tests, disputes the finding, saying it has confidence in the accuracy of the analyses it provides doctors and patients without sequencing normal DNA.

Moreover, a researcher at MD Anderson Cancer Center, while acknowledging some risk that tumor-only DNA could lead to wrong treatments, said normal DNA tests aren’t necessary to accurately identify most of the mutations considered to drive tumor growth.

The much bigger problem, said Kenna Shaw, executive director of MD Anderson’s Khalifa Institute for Personalized Cancer Therapy, who wasn’t involved in the study, is that only a fraction of patients matched to potentially effective medicines actually are being treated with them.

The divergent views reflect growing pains in the burgeoning effort to use genetic information to improve cancer treatment, a strategy known as precision medicine.

A growing number of cancer centers routinely sequence the DNA of many patients’ tumors to hunt for genetic mutations that fuel a cancer’s growth. Doctors use the test results to guide treatment, either by prescribing an approved drug that targets the mutations or by referring patients to a clinical trial testing an experimental treatment.

This strategy is beginning to transform cancer treatment, with more drugs becoming available for a variety of cancers and with scores of trials underway to test such agents.

“There is a lot of excitement about precision medicine,” said Victor Velculescu, co-director of the Cancer Biology Program at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and senior author of the study, which appears online in the journal Science Translational Medicine. But “we cannot have precision medicine without precision genomics.”

Genetic alterations are present in both tumors and in a person’s normal, or germline, DNA. But alterations found in both cancer and the normal tissue would be present essentially in all cells and in most cases not a cause of the cancer, researchers said.

Dr. Velculescu and his colleagues analyzed both tumor and normal DNA from 815 cancer patients and found 33% of so-called “actionable” mutations—those considered culprits when found in tumors—also were in a patient’s germline DNA. When multiple mutations were considered, such false positives affected 48% of the patients studied, the researchers said.

“We were surprised by the magnitude of the errors that can come out of this type of analysis” without also testing normal tissue, he said. “It would be a shame to use these targeted therapies and not use the right ones.”

Dr. Velculescu and his colleagues are co-founders of a company called Personal Genome Diagnostics Inc., which generated the data in the study and which markets a genomic test designed to evaluate both tumor and normal-tissue DNA. The study wasn’t critical of any specific company’s diagnostic test.

The study drew a rebuff from Foundation Medicine. “At best, it’s naive,” said Phil Stephens, chief scientific officer of the Cambridge, Mass.-based company. “At worst, it’s completely misleading.”

He agreed that mutations present in both the tumor and germline DNA generally aren’t driving the cancer. But he said “no responsible diagnostic company would ever report out” most of the mutations the Hopkins study considers as false positives.

Dr. Stephens said Foundation Medicine uses the entire medical literature on cancer-related genetic mutations to evaluate tumor DNA results. “We fundamentally believe we can find 100% of the druggable alterations that should be reported to physicians,” he said.

At MD Anderson, Dr. Shaw said, “it’s an overreach to suggest that we’re misdirecting so many patients” by not analyzing normal DNA. The role of the vast majority of detected alterations isn’t known—even in genes broadly regarded as potential culprits, she said. If the cancer role of specific mutation isn’t known, it generally isn’t reported to clinicians as a potential drug target.

MD Anderson is among the leaders in trying to match cancer patients with clinical trials testing potentially helpful drugs. Despite the excitement around precision medicine, though, Dr. Shaw said currently only 10% to 20% of patients with actionable mutations end up on a drug or in a trial. “The problem isn’t that we’re putting patients on the wrong drug,” she said.

Corrections & Amplifications:
Phil Stephens is chief scientific officer of Foundation Medicine. An earlier version of this article incorrectly stated his title was chief medical officer.

Write to Ron Winslow at

19,238 thoughts on “Study Sparks Debate on Accuracy of Genome Tests for Cancer Patients

  1. BUSH LEAGUE: Reggie Bush justcan’t make moves like this one anymore. Williams was a starting defensive lineman for the Alabama Crimson Tide in their 2011 and 2012 championship campaigns. raiders bady
    Williams confirmed the extension, which would make him the league’s highest-paid offensive tackle, on his own Twitter account. Head coach Jay Gruden confirmed after the game that Griffin sustained a concussion, and offered no timeline on his return.
    new england cheap jersey Jimmy Garoppolo’s performance is much more interesting, because he’s still a question mark. AsESPN’s Dan Graziano points out, though, it’s inevitable that the two sides will eventually come to terms on a deal.
    new orleans saints jersey
    Brady appealed the suspension, but with Goodell serving as arbitrator, the decision was upheld. Fans who couldn’t get into the auditorium could watch Goodell announce each selection on a large projection. go raiders f4l
    Injuries Panthers defensive end Frank Williams tore his achilles and is out for the season. The deal is worth $5 million,according to NFL Media’s Ian Rapoport.
    go raiders f4l Just have a look for yourself. There’s no official word on what exactly happened, but we’ll update when there’s more information.
    new england womens jersey

  2. Our headset is just as stunning just as inside picture. It arrived promptly. I’d advise choosing a towel over each coating as you hit that it off w / one steam iron. It does not steam over using merely a steamer. The particular iron is required. It is very delicate, so if you you should not trust your self using the towel as well as vapor iron, well take information technology to a certified. Awesome sound.

  3. Our headset ended up being as stunning like into the visualize. They came immediately. I would suggest choosing a towel over every single coating as you hit things away w / letter steam iron. It doesn’t steam out and merely a steamer. That iron ended up being necessary. It is very sensitive, so if you cannot trust your self aided by the towel plus steam iron, and then choose information technology to a pro. Beautiful sound.

  4. Durkin states he’ll pass up it following he retires nevertheless he’ll return to their office as a spectator. After all, he admits that Belmont is practically just like home. He or she lives only four units away. [url=]Cheap NFL Jerseys[/url]
    This editors will also be providing unique pricing for the complete Genocide Selection series. Readers is now able to individual most six quantities of the Stockpile for $95, including delivery.Your brands comprisePassage by way of Hell by ArmenAnush, The Fatal Night by MikayelShamtanchian, Death March by ShahenDerderian, The Criminal offenses in the Ages by SebuhAguni, Defying Fate by Aram and DirouhiAvedian, andOur Crossby Mirielle. Salpi. [url=]Cheap NFL Jerseys[/url]
    There was no record big difference after the 1st year; however, effects immediately after yr a pair of ended up thrilling. At two years associated with supplementation, the particular suggest WML volume of the placebo group increased whilst those that acquired hands tocotrienols continued to be unaffected. The primary investigator, Yuen, determined that supplementation with palm tocotrienols (Tocomin SupraBio) attenuates the growth of white colored make any difference wounds. [url=]fake oakley sunglasses[/url]
    Your Gambian had 9 commences for your team this coming year as well as ranking just one purpose. He already been with all the Timbers because 09. [url=]roshe run shoes[/url]
    Thursday: “Les Miserables,In Racine Cinema Guild, 2519 Northwestern Ave., Racine, (262) 633-4218; “Bleacher Bums,In Lakeside People, Rhode Core to the Martial arts disciplines, 514 56th Saint., Kenosha, (262) 657-7529
    oakley sunglasses

  5. I obtained it looking for a ideal gift of my mother. The headphone emerged in a pretty purple tied up container. This is the greatest searching present underneath their holiday tree!! The actual headphone in addition looked striking, but my mama is actually gigantic boned as well as the headphone are somewhat tight, and yet their a great gift! I prefer this.

  6. I ordered your trying to find a awesome gifts concerning my personal mama. Your headphone arrived within a striking purple tied package. This is the greatest looking gifts under that the xmas tree!! That headphone also looked awesome, still my mama is big boned and the headphone was somewhat tight, still its a good present! I appreciate this.

  7. Then you need to factor in that most websites are predominantly text and pictures, while the largest porn sites push streaming video. Whenever you load the ExtremeTech home page, you talking about a couple of megabytes, and then maybe 500 kilobytes should you load an article. When you stream porn, assuming a low resolution of 480 you taking a look at around 100 kilobytes per second which, over 15 minutes, is around 90 megabytes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.